The Truth About Publishing

Obtaining a mainstream publishing contract is the brass ring for most writers, but for new writers, the process is very serendipitous; luck is a huge factor. More often than not, new writers find rejections to be the norm and ultimately turn to self-publishing out of frustration. Most traditional houses are looking for a large platform to drive any future book sales. It’s why many Bravolebrities end up with “bestsellers” because they have millions of people following them, not because of their stellar content.

            That said, we recommend that our writers determine their goals and whether it’s worth their time pursuing the mainstream publisher. It all comes down to what I call knowing your “why” before you choose which direction you are going. Read the blog: “Know Your Why” to help determine which publication track to head down. To give you some background, in the publishing opportunities below are the pros and cons of each:

            Traditional Publishing: Most mainstream publishers do not accept direct submissions from indie authors; however, some do. For those who do not, you must find an agent to represent you. This leaves the indie author to send submissions directly to select mainstream publishers and literary agents simultaneously. Each submission, either for a mainstream publisher or an agent, must be tailored specifically to their guidelines. All guidelines can be found on their corresponding websites.

Here are the pros and cons for traditional publishing:

            Pros:

• Mainstream publishers attach a certain validity or “higher value” to your   work in the eyes of the reader/buyer

• Provide you with editors

• Provide you with graphic designers (cover/layout)

• Potentially provide Illustrators if needed – in the case of picture books, it can be harder to gain a publisher if the content is good, but they don’t like the illustrations.

• Marketing – (this is tricky because not all will do this for the indie author – many want you to show how you will market your book.)

 Cons:

• Sharing 15-20% of your profits

• Diminished creative license – what your overall vision for your book is and what the publisher wants may be at odds, and the publisher will typically have the ultimate say

• For picture books, they will most likely want to assign their own illustrator to the project, limiting the author’s ability to insert their original vision for the pictures

• The publisher owns ISBN# and controls the printing

           Self Publishing: The creation of Amazon has made it easy for anyone to self-publish their work. Once your manuscript is finished, you can upload it onto their platform and begin selling immediately. However, there is more to it than just throwing your work on Amazon and waiting for the money to come in—it’s not that simple. There is the formatting, cover design, ISBN#’s, and barcodes to purchase, and the marketing of your book.

            Here are the pros and cons of self-publishing:

Pros:

• Ability to publish

• Full creative license

• You retain 100% rights to the book – own ISBN# and 100% control over content and printing

• You set your price

 Cons:

• The perceived value of the book is diminished

• Indie author absorbs the cost of the following:

1. Upload to Amazon, Barnes & Noble.com, and IngramSpark

2. Editing costs – both content and copy

3. Beta Reads – not always done, but CLP considers this a critical step in the editing process

4. Graphic design – formatting, cover work, and marketing material

5. ISBN Number and barcode acquisition

6. Marketing costs – including public relations, the printing of proof copies, purchase and mailing costs of advance copies to media sources and various other marketing vehicles

• Sharing your profits with Amazon, Barnes & Noble, or IngramSpark – the 3 places CLP suggests you publish to maximize distribution channels

             Note: To self-publish, an indie author is not required to have beta-readers, editors, or graphic designers assist them in the process. So, yes, you can self-publish with little investment. However, CLP does not advocate for an indie author to avoid costs for beta reads, editing, or graphic designers. Instead, it perpetuates the theory that self-published books are of lesser quality. Quality should be paramount to any book published, whether mainstream or self-published. CLP works with each of our writers to keep their costs as low as possible without compromising quality.

            Hybrid/Boutique/Vanity Publishers: There are also hybrid publishers and boutique publishers. The hybrid publishers offer both a traditional option and a self-publishing option. Often, these are the traditional publishers that will accept direct submissions from authors. Know that experience has proven that most will come back with an acceptance letter, but it is for the self-publishing side. To sum it up: it’s a psychological play to get you to feel as though they “offered” you a contract, but you will pay the entire costs of publishing. Remember, if you have to pay one cent, it’s not a traditional publishing contract.

            Boutique publishers are smaller publishing houses that will pay for your publishing costs; most are like a traditional publisher but without the name recognition. Often these are confused with vanity or subsidy publishers, which are also small houses, but these require the author to pay to some degree the publication costs. They can offer varying proposals, some taking some of the costs in exchange for rights, for example. Read the contracts carefully, evaluating what they are offering and whether it will really yield better results for you than self-publishing.

            In the end, this is an individual decision, but I typically advise my clients, especially those fictional writers, to try and get a traditional contract, as they will always yield greater sales numbers than the average author without a platform will do on their own. The best way to approach is to set a particular number of months to submit to agents; if none bite after that, then it’s time to reevaluate if you will continue submissions or go self-publishing.

            When choosing that self-publisher, I highly recommend CLP or a firm like us, who are a cohesive team where each player knows the author and understands their goals. We handle every manuscript with extreme care and consideration because we are working toward delivering the dream of our author. We are not a production line like so many of these publishing houses that charge a flat fee, use AI to edit and lay out your interior, and produce a cover. CLP does not exist on volume but on quality. It’s not how many books we can produce that matters, but the quality of what we produce for our authors. It may sound corny, but it’s been our mission since we started to focus on substance over quantity.

            I hope this clears up many of your publishing questions. If you need more, please reach out via email, and I will be happy to answer any questions you have.

 

Happy Writing!

 

Next
Next

The Memoir Myth: Every Good Story is Book-Worthy